The Trial Notebook form epitomizes a comprehensive system designed to organize the myriad of components necessary for trial preparation, including techniques, strategies, and a structured compartmentalization of documents. Created by Vicki Voisin, ACP, and Christina L. Koch, ACP, it serves as an invaluable tool for legal professionals aiming to streamline their trial preparation process to ensure efficiency and preparedness. For a thorough understanding of how to construct the Ultimate Trial Notebook and elevate your trial readiness, click the button below to fill out the form.
The Trial Notebook, a cornerstone resource for legal professionals navigating the complexities of trial preparation and execution, embodies organized and structured litigation strategy. Crafted by Vicki Voisin, ACP, known as "The Paralegal Mentor," and Christina L. Koch, ACP, with both combining decades of experience in the legal field, this guide serves as an invaluable tool for paralegals and legal assistants. It covers a wide range of topics, from the initial stages of trial preparation to the details of managing electronic trial notebooks, laying out supplies, resources, and software choices crucial for effective trial support. With its comprehensive approach to organizing pleadings, motions, discovery, witnesses, exhibits, jury instructions, trial briefs, and more, this manual not only strives to enhance the proficiency and preparedness of legal staff but also emphasizes the importance of ethical considerations throughout the trial process. The guide draws on Voisin's extensive experience in ethical training and Koch's frontline experience in litigation support, offering practical insights and strategies to navigate the trials' challenging landscape confidently. Through its meticulously curated content, the Trial Notebook underscores the necessity for meticulous preparation, organization, and the pursuit of excellence in the paralegal profession, serving as a testament to Voisin and Koch's commitment to raising the bar for legal assistants everywhere.
Trial Notebook Techniques & Strategies
How to Create the Ultimate Trial Notebook
Be organized...Be Prepared!
Vicki Voisin, ACP
And
Christina L. Koch, ACP
©2010 Vicki Voisin, Inc. and Christina L. Koch, ACP
All rights reserved. No part of this handout may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means, including information storage and retrieval systems, without permission in writing from the copyright holder, except by a reviewer who may quote brief passages in a review.
Trial Notebook Techniques and Strategies
www.paralegalmentor.com
THE CONTENTS
About The Presenters
.....................................................................................................................
3
Module One:
The Introduction: What is a Trial Notebook?
6
Module Two:
Supplies, Resources and Your Trial First Aid Kit
8
Module Three:
When Do You Start Trial Preparation?
11
Module Four:
Choosing Your Software
..........................................................................
16
Module Five:
Detailing Your Trial Notebook
35
Module Six:
Trial Notebook Sections
47
Voir Dire, Opening Statements and Closing Arguments
49
Pleadings, Motions and Discovery
...........49
Witnesses
50
Exhibits
52
Jury Instructions/Trial Briefs
54
Settlement/Damages
Module Seven:
The Electronic Trial Notebook
64
Module Eight:
The Trial Preparation
67
Module Nine:
Conclusion
69
Index of Forms
................................................................................................................
71
©2010 Vicki Voisin Inc and Christina L. Koch ACP
All Rights Reserved
2
The Presenter: Vicki Voisin, ACP
Vicki Voisin, ACP , “The Paralegal Mentor,” is a nationally recognized author and speaker who delivers simple strategies for paralegals and other professionals to create success and satisfaction
by setting goals and determining the direction they will take their careers. Vicki spotlights resources, ethics issues, organizational tips, and other areas of continuing education to help paralegals and others reach their full potential.
She publishes Strategies for Paralegals Seeking Excellence, a bi-weekly ezine for paralegals and other professionals who want to create lasting success in their personal and professional lives. Additional information is available at www.paralegalmentor.com. She also hosts monthly Paralegal Mentor Mastermind Calls featuring guest experts who discuss issues of interest to the legal profession. For information or to register, go to www.paralegalmentor.com/mastermind- calls.html.
After spending more than twenty years in the paralegal field, Vicki launched her Paralegal Mentor Program so she could share her knowledge and experience with other paralegals.
Vicki speaks on issues of interest to the legal profession and is the creator and presenter of EthicsBasics®, a unique and enormously popular program designed to raise awareness of ethical concerns by legal professionals. She has worked as a paralegal for more than 20 years and is currently employed by Running Wise & Ford, PLC in their Charlevoix, Michigan office.
Utilizing the EthicsBasics format, Vicki has made numerous presentations throughout the United States, addressing paralegals and other members of the legal staff, in both law firms and corporations. She is also a frequent speaker at meetings of professional associations; these presentations have been approved for Attorney MCLE.
Vicki has authored articles of interest to attorneys and paralegals in publications on the state and national level, including the Michigan Bar Journal, Michigan Lawyers Weekly, The Michigan Paralegal, Legal Assistant Today, LAAM’s Newsbrief, and The Career Chronicle and Facts & Findings published by NALA. Many of those articles have been re-printed nationwide.
Vicki is an active member of the Legal Assistants Section of the State Bar of Michigan, having served as Chair in 2005-06. In 2000, she received the Mentor’s Award from the Section and she was named Legal Assistant of the Year by LAAM, an award that was named in her honor. In 2003, NALA recognized her leadership in the development of the paralegal profession with the presentation of its President’s Award.
She is a past president of the National Association of Legal Assistants (NALA) and until recently served on NALA’s Advanced Certification Board. Vicki presents Basic Ethics I and II, Advanced Ethics, Ethics & Technology, and Time Organization Techniques on NALA Campus LIVE! She presented Social Networking: Not Just For Kids Any More at the 2009 NALA Annual Convention & Educational Workshops, July 8-11, 2009, San Diego, California.
Questions may be directed to Vicki@paralegalmentor.com. Visit her blog at www.paralegalmentor.blogspot.com where she addresses matters of interest to legal professionals. Subscribe to her bi-weekly ezine titled Strategies for Paralegals seeking Excellence at www.paralegalmentor.com.
***Follow Vicki***
Twitter: http://www.Twitter.com/VickiVoisin
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/VickiVoisin
LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.comm/in/VickiVoisin
The Presenter: Christina L. Koch, ACP
Christina L. Koch, ACP is a NALA Advanced
Certified Paralegal in Trial Practice with more than twenty years of experience in the legal field. She received her Paralegal degree in 1991 and also holds a Bachelor of Science Degree in Management. She is a National Dean’s List Scholar.
In 2002, Christina joined the Omaha NE firm of Inserra & Kelley and is currently a Litigation Paralegal/Trial Practice Specialist. Her work with Inserra & Kelley includes
handling all aspects of litigation for the firm. She is adept in performing all aspects of litigation, including legal research, writing, discovery, investigative and analytical skills and preparation. Her experience includes the areas of personal injury, workers’ compensation, products liability, FELA and insurance defense.
She is a member of NALA, NePA, and a paralegal affiliate of the American Association of Justice. Christina completed the NALA LEAP program in 2009 and was named to the Paralegal Superstar Calendar of the nationwide Paralegal Gateway for March of 2008.
Christina has served on the Nebraska Paralegal Association Board of Directors since 2007 and is currently a member of the AAJ Paralegal Task Force Advisory Committee.
She is a nationally recognized author and speaker on various litigation topics and was a member of the faculty of the Trial Specialist Institute in Las Vegas, NV.
Christina is a freelance legal author, speaker and blogger and the founder of the Nebraska Paralegals list serve.
***Follow Christinai***
Twitter: http://twitter.com/ChristinaKoch
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/ChristinaLKoch
LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/in/christinakoch
4
Notice:
Warning of Copyright Protection: Any sample documents presented to you in this teleclass and are ALL copyright protected. Under no circumstances can the copy in these documents be used or reproduced, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of Vicki Voisin. The absence of a copyright notice on any given page or material should NOT be construed as an absence of copyright. These materials and documents are provided for sample purposes only and only for your personal use. They are not to be distributed or used in any other learning venues.
Legal Notice: This teleclass contains information gathered from many sources, as well as from the experiences of the author. It is produced for general reference and not as a substitute for independent verification by users when circumstances warrant. It is presented with the understanding that the author is not engaged in rendering any legal, accounting or psychological advice. In instances where the opinions or advice of legal, financial, psychological or other professional advice are appropriate, such professional counsel should be sought. The author disclaims any liability whatsoever for individuals’ use of any advice or information presented. Although the author has used care and diligence in the
preparation
of
this
presentation,
she
assumes
no
responsibility
for
errors
or
omissions.
5
Module One
The Introduction:
What Is a Trial Notebook?
Module One. What Is A Trial Notebook?
The biggest mistake attorneys and paralegals can make is to delay trial preparation until the week of the trial.
a. takes away any margin for error
b. may miss a key subpoena or document c. may omit critical elements of your claim
d. may fail to include evidence necessary to prove elements at trial
Ethics issues: The attorney must act with reasonable diligence on the client’s behalf and owes the client the duty of competency, as well as zealous representation. ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct 1.1 and 1.3
The trial notebook is your blueprint for trial and should be customized to the attorney who will try the case. The general rule is that it is organized in the same form and order that trial will progress.
Customary sections include:
Voir Dire
Opening Argument
Pretrial Orders/Motions
Pleadings
Plaintiff’s Witness List w/separate tabs for each witness
Defendant’s Witness List w/separate tabs for each witness
Plaintiff’s Exhibit List
Defendant’s Exhibit List
Closing Argument
Jury Instructions/Trial Briefs
Settlement/Damages
7
Module Two
Supplies, Resources
and
Your Trial First Aid Kit
Module Two. Supplies, Resources and Your Trial First Aid Kit
Tip: Keep basic supplies on hand, including:
several sizes of three or five ring binders
binder tabs
separator pages
three-ring college-ruled notebook paper
Tip: Keep your Trial First Aid Kit stocked.
Tip: Follow any rules re: cell phones; turn off alarms on any electronic devices, including watch alarms, BlackBerry, Palm Pilot, Kindle, etc.
9
CHECKLIST – TRIAL FIRST AID KIT
1.BASIC TRIAL SUPPLIES Paperclips Scissors
Scotch Tape
Small Stapler/Staples Paper Puncher
_____Blue Pens (4)
Black Pens (4)
Red Pens (2)
Highlighters (3 – different colors)
_____ Post-It Notes
Colored flags (you will find these near the post-it notes) Pencils (4) and Pencil Sharpener
_____ Legal Note Pads
2.COMPUTER SUPPLIES Laptop
_____ Flash Drive
Extra USB cord
_____ Presenter/Laser Pointer
_____ PowerPoint Presentation downloaded to Laptop
3.ADDITIONAL SUPPLIES
Extra Batteries
Tylenol and Advil (some people cannot take Advil)
_____ Cough Drops
_____ Chewing Gum
Hand Sanitizer
Hand Lotion
_____ Carmex/Chap Stick
_____ Petty Cash ($20.00 in bills and $3.00 - $5.00 in change)
_____ Protein Bars
4.BUSINESS SUPPLIES Attorney Business Cards
Paralegal Business Cards
_____ Any demonstrative exhibits?
5.ADDITIONAL SUPPLIES FOR THIS TRIAL ONLY A.
B.
C.
D.
10
Filling out the Trial Notebook form requires a methodical approach to ensure that every section is completed accurately and comprehensively. This form is a crucial tool for organizing trial preparation and ensuring that all necessary materials and information are at your fingertips when they are needed the most. The steps provided below are designed to guide you through the process of completing the form, ensuring that nothing is missed and that you are fully prepared for trial. Remember, the goal is to be organized and prepared, enabling you to effectively support your legal team.
Once you have completed these steps, you should take the time to review the entire notebook, ensuring that everything is correctly placed, easily accessible, and thoroughly prepared. Remember, the effectiveness of a trial notebook lies in both its preparation and its usability during the trial. Getting familiar with its contents and organization before the trial will significantly enhance its utility when you need it most.
What is a Trial Notebook?
A Trial Notebook is a comprehensive collection of materials, documents, and information assembled by legal professionals to use during a trial. This organized resource contains vital sections like voir dire, opening statements, closing arguments, pleadings, motions, discovery, witnesses, exhibits, jury instructions, trial briefs, and sections covering settlement and damages. Its purpose is to ensure the legal team is prepared and organized, enabling them to present their case effectively.
Who creates the Trial Notebook?
Usually, a Trial Notebook is created by experienced paralegals or legal assistants under the guidance of attorneys. Paralegals like Vicki Voisin, ACP and Christina L. Koch, ACP, who have extensive experience in trial preparation and litigation support, often take the lead in compiling these notebooks. Their expertise ensures that the notebook is thorough, organized, and immediately useful for the trial team.
When should one start preparing the Trial Notebook?
Preparation of the Trial Notebook should begin as early as possible, ideally at the onset of taking a case to trial. Early preparation allows for the inclusion and organization of all necessary documentation, evidence, and information, enabling adjusted and additional materials to be accommodated as the trial preparation progresses.
What are the key sections of a Trial Notebook?
The key sections include Voir Dire, Opening Statements, Closing Arguments, Pleadings, Motions, Discovery, Witnesses, Exhibits, Jury Instructions, Trial Briefs, Settlement, and Damages. Each section serves a specific purpose, contributing to the comprehensive support and preparation of the legal team for trial.
How does technology impact the creation and use of a Trial Notebook?
Technology significantly enhances the creation and utilization of a Trial Notebook by offering digital formats for organization and easy retrieval of information. The trend towards Electronic Trial Notebooks allows legal teams to access and share vital information efficiently, making updates and changes more manageable. Software choices play a crucial role in organizing these notebooks, with specific applications designed to meet the unique needs of trial preparation.
Can Trial Notebooks be used for all types of trials?
Yes, Trial Notebooks can be adapted for use in various types of trials, including but not limited to personal injury, workers' compensation, products liability, and insurance defense. The customizability of the notebook's contents and organization makes it an invaluable tool for any legal proceeding.
What is the importance of a Trial First Aid Kit?
A Trial First Aid Kit refers to the inclusion of essential supplies, resources, and quick reference materials within the Trial Notebook or as an accompanying component. This kit ensures that the trial team has immediate access to necessary items and information that might be needed quickly during the course of a trial.
How can one obtain permission to reproduce parts of the Trial Notebook?
Permission to reproduce parts of the Trial Notebook for educational or review purposes must be obtained in writing from the copyright holders, Vicki Voisin, Inc. and Christina L. Koch, ACP. This ensures respect for the intellectual property of the authors while allowing for the responsible use of the material within the legal and educational communities.
When filling out the Trial Notebook form, it's easy to rush through the process or overlook details that can be crucial for making a strong, organized presentation in court. Here are six common mistakes to avoid:
One common mistake is not fully utilizing the guidelines provided in the introductory sections. This foundational step is crucial for understanding the overall structure and purpose of the Trial Notebook. By skipping this part, you may miss out on helpful strategies for organizing your notebook in a way that best supports your case.
Another oversight is ignoring the recommended supplies, resources, and the trial first aid kit outlined in Module Two. These materials are not randomly suggested; they are aimed at ensuring you have all the necessary tools at your disposal during trial preparation and in the courtroom. This includes both physical supplies and software recommendations that can streamline the organization of your evidence and arguments.
It's also a mistake to underestimate the importance of timing in trial preparation, as highlighted in Module Three. Waiting until the last minute to start organizing your Trial Notebook can lead to missed details, poorly organized arguments, and ultimately, a weaker case presentation. Early and continuous preparation allows for thorough review and revisions, increasing your readiness for trial.
People often bypass detailing their Trial Notebook effectively, as advised in Module Five. This step is about more than just filling in sections; it's about critically evaluating and organizing your material so that it's easily accessible and compelling. Poor organization within your notebook can lead to delays and missed opportunities during the trial.
A critical error is ignoring the section on the Electronic Trial Notebook within Module Seven. In today's digital age, being adept with electronic tools and understanding how to integrate technology into your trial preparation is essential. This includes knowing how to organize digital files, present electronic evidence, and ensure your technical setup is fail-proof during proceedings.
Finally, not dedicating ample time to the Trial Preparation module is a significant oversight. This section is designed to put all the pieces together, emphasizing the application of earlier strategies into a cohesive plan. Skipping this step can result in a disjointed presentation, where evidence, arguments, and delivery are not as polished or persuasive as they could be.
Avoiding these mistakes during the preparation of your Trial Notebook can dramatically increase your odds of success in court. Each module of the guidebook provides valuable insights that, when followed, contribute to a well-organized, persuasive legal argument. Always remember that preparation is the key to trial success.
When preparing for trial, legal professionals often use a Trial Notebook as a comprehensive resource and guide through the myriad stages of trial preparation and execution. However, this crucial tool does not stand alone in the arsenal of documents and forms utilized to ensure a thorough and organized approach to litigation. Beyond the Trial Notebook, there are several key documents and forms that play pivotal roles throughout the legal process, each serving its unique purpose to support a case's strategic development, presentation, and follow-up. Understanding these documents can significantly enhance one's preparedness and efficacy in any legal setting.
The journey through litigation involves a complex interplay of strategy, evidence, and legal precedent, making it essential for legal professionals to have a thorough understanding and organization of numerous documents and forms beyond the Trial Notebook. These documents not only aid in the meticulous preparation of a case but also streamline the process, ensuring that nothing is left to chance. It's the combination of these tools that equip attorneys and legal teams with the ability to present the most compelling case possible.
The trial notebook form, in its essence, mirrors the structure and purpose of a project management plan. Like a project management plan, a trial notebook organizes sequences of activities, responsibilities, and deadlines to ensure the efficient progress of a project – in this case, the project is the trial. Both documents serve as a compass for navigating through complex tasks, providing a detailed layout of the process, along with resources, timelines, and critical milestones. They are instrumental in ensuring that team members are aligned with the objectives, understand their roles, and are aware of the key dates and deliverables.
Furthermore, the trial notebook form bears a resemblance to an academic syllabus. An academic syllabus outlines the scope of a course, including the subjects to be covered, readings, assignments, and expectations. Similarly, a trial notebook delineates the trajectory of a trial, encompassing pleadings, motions, evidence, witness lists, and legal arguments. Both documents act as blueprints that guide participants through a sequenced learning and operational process, ensuring comprehensive coverage of all necessary components and facilitating preparedness and participation.
Another document similar to the trial notebook form is a comprehensive business plan. Business plans articulate the vision of a venture, detailing strategies for marketing, operations, and financial planning. Paralleling this, a trial notebook form encapsulates the strategy and tactics of a legal case, including the presentation of evidence, narratives for opening statements and closing arguments, and outlines for direct and cross-examinations. Both are foundational tools that organize and present complex information in a structured way to secure funding or, in the case of a trial notebook, to win a case.
The trial notebook form also shares an affinity with operation manuals used in various industries. These manuals provide detailed instructions on the execution of tasks, operation of systems, or compliance with procedures and protocols. Similarly, a trial notebook offers guidelines and organized information to legal teams for the execution of a trial, from voir dire through to verdict. Both serve as indispensable reference materials that ensure tasks are performed efficiently, correctly, and in accordance with established protocols, contributing to the smooth operation of complex processes.
When tackling the task of filling out the Trial Notebook form, it's crucial to apply discretion and attentiveness. Below are essential dos and don'ts to ensure the process is both efficient and effective.
Dos:
Don'ts:
When preparing for trial, the concept of a Trial Notebook is pivotal, yet surrounded by several misconceptions. Understanding these misconceptions is critical for legal professionals who aim to be thoroughly prepared and organized. Below is a list elucidating ten common misconceptions about the Trial Notebook and providing clarifications to each.
Misconception #1: The Trial Notebook is only beneficial for trials. While its name suggests so, the Trial Notebook is incredibly useful in all stages of litigation, not just at trial. It aids in organization and preparation well before entering the courtroom.
Misconception #2: One size fits all for Trial Notebooks. Contrary to this belief, Trial Notebooks should be tailored to suit the specific needs of each case. The organizational structure can vary significantly depending on the case's complexity and nature.
Misconception #3: Creating a Trial Notebook is too time-consuming. While it does require an upfront time investment, the efficiency and ease it brings to trial preparation ultimately save time and reduce stress.
Misconception #4: Electronic Trial Notebooks are risky due to potential technical issues. Although technology can sometimes fail, safeguards such as backups and ensuring that devices are charged and in good working order can mitigate these risks significantly.
Misconception #5: Only paralegals and legal assistants need to understand the Trial Notebook. It’s beneficial for all members of the legal team, including attorneys, to be familiar with the Trial Notebook's layout and content for streamlined collaboration and strategy formulation.
Misconception #6: The Trial Notebook is just about organizing documents. Beyond document organization, it encompasses strategizing, collecting important reference materials, and ensuring accessibility of critical information during trial.
Misconception #7: Static content suffices for a Trial Notebook. The content of a Trial Notebook should be dynamic, allowing for updates and additions as the case evolves and new information comes to light.
Misconception #8: Everything needs to be included in the Trial Notebook. While thoroughness is essential, discernment is key. Including only pertinent information ensures the Trial Notebook remains a practical, efficient tool.
Misconception #9: The Trial Notebook’s usefulness ends with the trial. Post-trial, it serves as a valuable reference for appeals, settlements, and analyzing the case for future strategic improvements.
Misconception #10: Only seasoned legal professionals can prepare effective Trial Notebooks. With guidance and practice, even those new to the legal field can master the art of creating comprehensive and useful Trial Notebooks.
Dispelling these misconceptions is the first step toward leveraging the full potential of Trial Notebooks. Through proper understanding and utilization, a well-prepared Trial Notebook becomes an indispensable asset for any legal team, enhancing organization, preparation, and ultimately, the effectiveness of trial presentation.
Creating an effective trial notebook is essential for legal professionals to organize and present their case efficiently. Here are key takeaways about filling out and using the Trial Notebook form:
By following these guidelines, legal professionals can create a comprehensive and effective trial notebook, enhancing their trial preparation and performance. The key is to be organized, detailed, and prepared, ensuring that you have quick access to all necessary information during the trial process.
Cms 1 Mn - Filing instructions include options for faxing or mailing the completed form to the designated office for processing.
Form 1065 - Helps partners in a business entity determine their individual tax responsibilities.